Butt Smoking Help

Cornwallis

Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2023
Messages
14
Media
4
Reaction score
40
Location
Perth , Australia
G'day Smokers:)

Can I please get some feedback with possible fixes and advice for cooking my first Boston Butt.

The meat of choice was an 8.6lb (3.9kg) Pork shoulder Boston Butt.

I started the process with a 24hrs brine and injection, and that truly looked like it gave the meat a huge head start when removed from the brine. Standard process for the rub, mustard and two of our favourite rubs.

I fired the Series 3 up to 250 F (121c) just to warm her up and to get some good smoke going. As I was doing a low and slow, I dropped the temperature down to 224 F (107c) and was more than prepared for the 10 hours that I allocated for the slow process.

I got to the 4 hours quite easily and the temperature was very even, and the meat was moist. At 5 hours I had an internal temperature of approximately 165 F (72 c) and then I wrapped it paper,

Over the next 4 hours the internal temperature climbed slowly but surely to the goal of 190 f (88c). As I had the door open a few times, I let the butt hit 194 F (90c) for the last 30 mins. All in all the butt was in for 9.5 hours, and then wrapped in towels and placed in the esky for 45 minutes.

The meat on the butt in some areas fell away like we dream about, where in other areas it was still tough, it was cooked, (tasted great) but nowhere near being pulled pork. The bone never pulled out, (I so wanted that to happen) and when I cut it out (yep, cut it out) it was huge, T-REX huge.

There were still some good fatty bits that had not broken down, the meat in general was magic, tasted fantastic, awesome smoke ring, smoke taste was good, bark was ok in places, though one loses some of that due to wrapping.

I am a little lost to where I may have gone wrong and would appreciate all the advice that I can get for the next one I do.

Thanking you all in advance:cool:
 

Attachments

  • Bone.JPG
    Bone.JPG
    213.7 KB · Views: 50
  • Butt 1.jpg
    Butt 1.jpg
    195.8 KB · Views: 21
  • Butt 2.jpg
    Butt 2.jpg
    169.4 KB · Views: 20
  • Trimmed Butt.JPG
    Trimmed Butt.JPG
    203.5 KB · Views: 22
by your process your spot on other than let it cook open for more bark you could spray it with apple juice to keep it moist till you wrap it .I do most of my smoking at 225 like you say low and slow is the best you did nothing wrong in my opinion your going to get different results depending on cuts .smoking is a learning thing you learn as you go trial an error
 
G'day Smokers:)

Can I please get some feedback with possible fixes and advice for cooking my first Boston Butt.

The meat of choice was an 8.6lb (3.9kg) Pork shoulder Boston Butt.

I started the process with a 24hrs brine and injection, and that truly looked like it gave the meat a huge head start when removed from the brine. Standard process for the rub, mustard and two of our favourite rubs.

I fired the Series 3 up to 250 F (121c) just to warm her up and to get some good smoke going. As I was doing a low and slow, I dropped the temperature down to 224 F (107c) and was more than prepared for the 10 hours that I allocated for the slow process.

I got to the 4 hours quite easily and the temperature was very even, and the meat was moist. At 5 hours I had an internal temperature of approximately 165 F (72 c) and then I wrapped it paper,

Over the next 4 hours the internal temperature climbed slowly but surely to the goal of 190 f (88c). As I had the door open a few times, I let the butt hit 194 F (90c) for the last 30 mins. All in all the butt was in for 9.5 hours, and then wrapped in towels and placed in the esky for 45 minutes.

The meat on the butt in some areas fell away like we dream about, where in other areas it was still tough, it was cooked, (tasted great) but nowhere near being pulled pork. The bone never pulled out, (I so wanted that to happen) and when I cut it out (yep, cut it out) it was huge, T-REX huge.

There were still some good fatty bits that had not broken down, the meat in general was magic, tasted fantastic, awesome smoke ring, smoke taste was good, bark was ok in places, though one loses some of that due to wrapping.

I am a little lost to where I may have gone wrong and would appreciate all the advice that I can get for the next one I do.

Thanking you all in advance:cool:
Hey Cornwallis,
You seem to have a great plan going on.
Do another one the same way bit as Cowboy says shoot for 205f.
Those visuals are important, seeing the meat pull back is important and use your temp probe to probe the tenderness. It should penetrate smooth and easy, any resistance just go a little longer.
Butts will stay plenty hot for hours in a cooler. Use this time to plan your serve time. If dinner is at noon back up your start time with that 2-3 hour cushion.
That part of your roast that wouldn't pull is indicative of roast needing more time.
 
Yep. I use two probes when cooking a butt. When the lowest one hits 204-205 I'll pull it. 198 is a roast and you'll need a knife. Although I never brine them so that could change things a little. I just dry rub and on the smoker. If I'm trying to speed things up I'll wrap at the stall, otherwise I just let it ride. My last two butts took 17 hours at 225 on an 1150 Pro.
 

Latest Discussions

Back
Top